Currently, HIV non-disclosure is a legal risk for criminalization in Canada. Non-disclosure can lead to an aggravated sexual assault charge, the most severe of assault charges in Canada, leading to jailtime and sex offender registration for life. No other medical condition has been criminalized in this way.
Fact Sheet – HIV Non-Disclosure and the Criminal Law – Department of Justice Canada
Over the past two decades, there have been almost 200 HIV-related criminal convictions in Canada, including convictions where there has been no HIV transmission. Canada’s long history of criminalizing PLHIV is rooted in stigma and outdated science.
Advancing HIV Justice –
HIV Justice Network
Decades of HIV research has led to significant advancements in the prevention and treatment, of HIV. Years of evidence show that when on effective treatment and with an undetectable viral load, people living with HIV cannot pass it on. Undetectable equals untransmittable, or U=U.
The Power of Undetectable –
CATIE
Jennifer Murphy was convicted in 2013 of aggravated sexual assault for not disclosing her HIV status to a sexual partner. In August 2022, she was acquitted of her conviction by the Ontario Court of Appeal, setting precedence for future HIV non-disclosure cases.
HIV criminalization has dire consequences on the quality of life for PLHIV by reinforcing stigmatization and creating institutional barriers that impede CANFAR’s mission of seeking out testing, treatment, and care. While the federal government engaged in community consultations earlier this year to address HIV stigma within the criminal justice system, no changes to the Criminal Code have yet been implemented, leaving PLHIV vulnerable to social stigma and unjust criminal charges.
Government consultations on modernizing the criminal justice system’s response to HIV non-disclosure –
Government of Canada